RockyMountainNews.com
Advertisement

Dani Broe
Age: 22
Hometown: Colorado Springs
Education and experience: A recent University of Colorado at Boulder graduate with a degree in psychology. Student taught at Westminster's Arapahoe Ridge Elementary School.
Why teaching? As a freshman, Broe pondered majoring in journalism or medicine, then chose psychology. Friends urged her to become a teacher. "I don't know," she said. "I just feels right." Video »



Online extras
Video essay, part 1: Three new teachers discuss their classrooms, how their education prepared them and the effect of a school's location on student discipline.
Click here »

Video essay, part 2: They face special education with confidence, but three new teachers know there's a wide range of students with different needs.
Click here »

Video essay, part 3: How prepared are new instructors to meet teacher requirements and students' academic goals? Three new teachers tackle standards.
Click here »

Video essay, part 4: Perhaps the most challenging aspect of teaching isn't dealing with students; it's with their parents.
Click here »

Video essays, part 5: The three new teachers reflect on the past year and talk about their futures in education.
Dani Broe »
Stephanie Leija »
Erin O'Grady »

Why teaching? Three newcomers to the profession explain why they want to be in the classroom.
Erin O'Grady »
Stephanie Leija »
Dani Broe »

Photo essay: A look inside the classrooms. Click here »

Reader forum: Does Colorado prepare its teachers well? Sound off on the state of education. Click here »

Teacher standards: A look at what new teachers must know to earn licensure. Click here »

Colorado Senate Bill 154: In 1999, Gov. Bill Owens signed into law a bill concerning performance-based teaching programs.
Click here »

360° photography: Virtual reality photos show how classroom set-ups affect discipline. Click here »




More stories
Part 5: In their own words
Main story: A learning experience
Dani Broe: Student teaching was most valuable
Stephanie Leija: A few words bring immeasurable joy
Erin O'Grady: Personal, academic triumphs in first year

Part 4: Parents and the community
Main story: Working with parents
Dani Broe: Parterning with parents
Stephanie Leija: Immigrant students a unique challenge
Erin O'Grady: Cultural gaps test teachers

Part 3: Standards
Main story: High-stakes standards
Dani Broe: Work sample a large hurdle
Stephanie Leija: New teacher's road not easy
Erin O'Grady: No simple answers to teaching reading
PLACE test: Testing teachers
Statistics: How prepared are Colorado's teachers?

Part 2: Special education
Stephanie Leija: Special needs struggle
Dani Broe: Hands-on training in special needs
Erin O'Grady: 23 students, 23 'classes'
Higher education: Special education requirements
Statistics: A look at special education

Part 1: Discipline
Main story: Ready, set, teach!
Erin O'Grady: Inner-city teacher struggles for control
Stephanie Leija: Teacher puts respect first
Dani Broe: Student teacher: managing kids learned on the job
Higher education: Classroom management requirements
Statistics: Colorado teachers grade readiness




About this series
This is the second part in a series examining teacher preparation in Colorado through the eyes of two young teachers and one college senior preparing for a teaching career.

This report examines the formidable challenge young teachers face from special education and first-time English learners.

The first installment details how prepared teachers are to deal with classroom discipline and management.
First installment »

The third installment illustrates how well first-year teachers are equipped to meet teacher and student academic standards.
Third installment »

The fourth installment deals with teachers' abilities to interact with parents and the community.
Fourth installment »

The fifth installment looks at the past year in the teachers' own words.
Fifth installment »



Hands-on training in special needs

Teachers-to-be such as Dani Broe go into real classrooms to get feel for things to come

By Julie Poppen
News Staff Writer

The brown bag lunch discussion is supposed to be about new state standards for teachers. Judging from the participants' glazed expressions, the topic doesn't spark much interest.

When talk turns to special-needs students, however, the University of Colorado teacher-education students perk up.

They put their lunches aside and lean forward. They want answers.

"I never realized how vulnerable you are going to feel," CU student McKenzie Ray says. "I think that's ridiculous we don't have any training in special ed."

It seems clear that just how to teach special-needs students, particularly when they're mixed into regular classrooms, has eluded some of them.

Last semester, Ray and several other teacher-education students, including CU senior Dani Broe, spent one day a week observing classes at Broomfield's Mountain View Elementary School.

Mountain View is known as a "center school" in the Adams 12 Five Star School District. The school houses the self-contained special-education programs, along with a program for hearing-impaired and deaf students.

This is where Broe and her peers get a firsthand look at how students with special needs are educated in public schools. And it's a lot different from the education-theory classes they took earlier in their college careers.

Ray laments that those classes didn't address "what to do when a kid screams out loud in the middle of class."

Broe says that special education was discussed "extensively" in some of her classes, including the lengthy process teachers and school staff go through to place a child in special-education programs.

"I feel like I have been prepared as well as one could be from a university classroom perspective," Broe says. "We've also discussed what our role as teachers is for special-ed and ESL (English as a Second Language) students and that there are tons of resources out there for us as long as we know where to look."

One CU course had Broe helping a Korean student with his reading and writing at his home once a week for an entire semester. Some of her early introductory courses had students observing or role-playing the process by which students are placed in special-education programs and learning about the legal requirements involved.

As a child, Broe volunteered at a therapeutic horseback-riding center in Colorado Springs, where she worked "with all kinds of different people" with special needs. In seventh grade, she spent her school year mentoring and offering assistance to a physically and mentally disabled ninth-grader.

She feels less prepared to work with ESL students. "I haven't had a whole lot of experience with (ESL) in the classroom setting," she says.

Linda Molner, who runs CU's teacher-licensure program, says Broe knows enough to get started, but she acknowledges that teachers do need different skills than they did 20 years ago.

"Second-language learners had dropped out of school by eighth grade because they weren't getting served," Molner says. "You never saw the special-ed kids. They were out in the trailer."

***

In late November, Broe spent a day observing all the special programs at Mountain View, beginning with a gifted and talented classroom of fourth- and fifth-graders, who are working with complicated fractions.

She moved onto a weekly counseling session for special-education students, where the vast range of learning needs becomes evident.

Nine students with a range of learning disabilities and emotional and behavioral problems sit in a group on the floor with a counselor, their teacher and a teaching assistant.

They are a playing a memory game that helps them process their emotions. Cards with words including lonely, angry and scared are face up on the floor, then turned over. The students pick cards from a new pile and try to match them to the words they can no longer see. They talk about situations that make them feel those emotions.

A child named Jordan sits on his knees and fidgets despite an earlier warning to be still.

"Jordan, sit on your bottom or go to the time-away room," the teaching assistant says.

As the class ends, Jordan hangs back from his classmates heading for the cafeteria then admits to his teacher he doesn't have a lunch.

Broe also visited a preschool classroom of hearing-impaired children. The children are playing a game to practice their communication skills. All the youngsters wear FM auditory trainers — headsets that amplify the teacher's voice and cut background noise.

Broe wears a similar microphone and headset when she teaches the 22 third-graders in teacher Vince Ardito's class one afternoon. Two of the students are hearing-impaired. A sign-language translator is always in the room.

Broe is giving a lesson about the weather. The rambunctious students take what seems like hours to follow Broe's simple instructions. As they cut out paper thermometers, the noise level mounts.

"Guys, it is so noisy in here," says Broe, looking like a switchboard operator with the headset on. "I know it's an activity that's kind of busy. But it's so loud."

In addition to handling the chaos around her, Broe must also be cognizant of where she is in the room, Ardito says.

"You have to be in the habit of watching the interpreter to make sure you're not moving too fast," he says.

Veteran teacher Terry Donnelly, a literacy-resource teacher who coordinates Mountain View's partnership with CU, says a recent college graduate can't possibly know how to effectively teach every single student.

"They're much better-prepared in content areas than they are in dealing with management or special-needs kids," Donnelly says. "There is very little way they can become adept at that without experiencing it."

This semester, Broe's last, she will be regularly evaluated as she student teaches full time at Arapahoe Ridge Elementary School, also in Adams 12, in teacher Marnie Danielski's fifth-grade class. Individualizing instruction for each child is one of eight broad categories evaluators will use to gauge Broe's performance.

The class has some bilingual students, one emotionally disturbed student who often leaves class to work with a social worker, and six students who aren't technically classified as special education but are struggling and receive special services. There are two gifted kids and two kids with attention-deficit disorder — one who is on medication and another who is not.

Danielski calls the classroom demographics "typical." And she believes Broe will do just fine.

"She seems to do an excellent job with all the different levels," Danielski says. "She kind of has a natural ability. It's not something she's been taught."

As Broe enters her final semester, she firmly believes that each student is important.

In her final children's literature class at CU's Boulder campus, CU associate professor Shelby Wolf, who brought her giant white stuffed dog Nana to class, urges the teaching students to "look for the magic in all children."

Wolf was crying.

So was Broe.

Contact Julie Poppen at (303) 892-5176 or poppenj@RockyMountainNews.com.

Advertisement
Advertisement
SITE SERVICES
PARTNERS
SERVICES
PROGRAMS